Hobby Lobby at The Marketplace of Warsaw was supposed to be open by now. The latest public estimate puts the opening in the first quarter of 2027. The center hasn't been waiting, though. A store that isn't built yet has already done the job an anchor tenant does, which is to bring other stores in behind it.
Three Updates Said Fall, Then One Said 2027
For almost a year, every public update pointed to fall 2026. Then one update moved the date. Here is the order:
- September 2025: Sullivan Wickley, the company that owns the Marketplace, told the Times-Union the goal was to open Hobby Lobby at 2884 Frontage Road "by fall" 2026.
- October 2025: When the Warsaw Common Council approved the city's share of the project, community and economic development director Jeremy Skinner said the site should be ready by March. He expected Hobby Lobby to try to finish "before the holiday of next year, so some time around October of 2026," InkFreeNews reported.
- February 2026: When Five Below was announced, both stores were "expected to open this fall," according to News Now Warsaw's report in the Times-Union.
- July 2026: At the Warsaw Redevelopment Commission's budget meeting, Councilman Mike Klondaris asked when Hobby Lobby would be up and running. Skinner said he was being told the first quarter of 2027, InkFreeNews reported. The same meeting described the project as "soon-to-be-under construction."
The new date came up as a single question in the middle of a budget meeting. That explains why many people still expect a fall opening. The first quarter of 2027 is still an estimate, not a confirmed opening day.
Why This Store Takes Longer Than the Others
Most of the Marketplace's comeback has involved putting stores into empty storefronts that were already there. Hobby Lobby is taking a different route. It's tearing down part of the building and replacing it with something much larger.
The store will run from the left of Planet Fitness across the space that used to hold Shoe Sensation and the BMV. According to InkFreeNews, Skinner told the council that section would be demolished and "a new 50,000-ish (square foot) building will be built, connected to that shopping center." He estimated about 20,000 to 25,000 square feet would come down, so the new store will be roughly twice the size of what it replaces.
The February report from News Now Warsaw in the Times-Union said the same thing in different words. Hobby Lobby would build a 50,000-square-foot store "instead of using the existing vacant storefront space," replacing a row of empty stores on the east end.
Moving into an existing storefront mostly means interior work and a new sign. Building new means demolition, site prep and construction of a large retail building before any shelves go in. A timeline that started with "site ready by March" was always going to be tight for a fall opening.
The Deadline Written Into the City's Money
Warsaw has money tied to this project, and the terms explain why the city follows the timeline closely.
In October 2025, InkFreeNews reported that the council voted 6-0 to approve a memorandum of understanding with Sullivan Wickley and a $250,000 loan from the city's economic development revolving loan fund. The loan is forgiven once Hobby Lobby receives its certificate of occupancy. The money was split into $100,000 from the 2025 budget and $150,000 from the 2026 budget. If the project isn't finished by August 2027, the loan has to be repaid to the city with interest. Skinner said he didn't expect that to happen.
A first-quarter 2027 opening would still come in months before that August 2027 deadline. So the delay means a later opening than people were told, but it doesn't put the city's agreement at risk.
The city also chose this site partly on cost. Skinner said other Hobby Lobby proposals discussed over the years, at "different locations," had been looking at "anywhere from $3.5 million." This one cost the city $250,000. Mayor Jeff Grose projected 35 to 50 new retail jobs.
Council President Jack Wilhite, making the motion, called it "probably the most desired and highly anticipated redevelopment in our recent history," according to InkFreeNews.
How Empty the Marketplace Was
That level of interest makes more sense once you remember how bad things got. Skinner reminded the council that the city issued a bond for The Marketplace of Warsaw "when it basically was about 90% empty."
The February coverage in the Times-Union filled in the background. City officials got involved after many tenants left, the property badly needed repairs, and there was concern the whole center could slide further. The city put in a $1.4 million bond in 2022 for the first improvements. Sullivan Wickley has spent about five years on the turnaround.
Since then, the center has added Gabe's, Bealls, Planet Fitness and Ollie's. The bond is paid back by a tax increment financing district built around the center. In July, Skinner described the Marketplace TIF to the Redevelopment Commission, as InkFreeNews reported, as a "pass-through" that collects tax revenue from the property and uses it to pay the bond. The 2027 bond payment is $151,748.
When the council approved the Hobby Lobby deal, the stated hope was that a big anchor would help Sullivan Wickley "fill the little spaces remaining with some additional tenants." That plan started working before construction even got going.
Five Below Followed the Announcement, Not the Opening
In February 2026, Sullivan Wickley signed a lease with Five Below. Five Below is a national discount chain with about 1,900 stores. Its Warsaw location takes about 10,000 square feet on the west side of the center, between Bealls and Ollie's. Around half a dozen storefronts had sat empty there for years. The renovation included a new facade. John Murphy, Sullivan Wickley's chief financial officer and partner, called the store a secondary anchor.
Murphy was clear about why Five Below signed. He told News Now Warsaw that he credited Hobby Lobby for the deal:
"People like to follow Hobby."
Five Below committed to the center based on a Hobby Lobby that was still on paper.
Five Below's store page now lists the Warsaw store at 2804 Frontage Road, Suite 6. Posted hours are 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. on Sunday. It also offers buy online and pick up in store, same-day delivery and helium balloons. The phone number is (574) 328-7224.
What's Left to Fill
Once both stores are open, Murphy said, "the center will be mostly full." The Five Below addition leaves only a few storefronts vacant.
The biggest open question nearby is the empty Indiana Tech building. In February, InkFreeNews reported that there had been talks about reusing it. No tenant was named.
Here's where things stand for anyone driving past on Frontage Road this November:
| Space | Status | Latest public date |
|---|---|---|
| Five Below, west side between Bealls and Ollie's | Listed on Five Below's store locator with posted hours | Announced February 2026 for fall |
| Hobby Lobby, east end next to Planet Fitness | New 50,000-square-foot building replacing the former Shoe Sensation and BMV row | First quarter of 2027, per July 2026 city update |
| City loan deadline | $250,000 forgiven once Hobby Lobby gets its certificate of occupancy | Project due by August 2027 |
| Former Indiana Tech building | Vacant, reuse discussed | No tenant named as of February 2026 |
Hobby Lobby will be the last big piece of a project that began in 2022 with a center that was about 90% empty. Its late opening is the only part of the plan that's running behind, and the tenant it was supposed to attract is already open.
Shopping centers near U.S. 30 filling back up are part of the bigger picture of what's happening around your home and what it's worth. If you'd like to know how the latest changes in Warsaw affect your property, Berto Barrera and the team can walk you through it in English or Spanish. Get your free home valuation and see where your home stands today.